Eagle Cap Insurance

An independent agency providing personalized health, life, Medicare, and business insurance solutions, helping individuals and businesses find the right coverage for long-term protection and peace of mind.

Contact Us


Disability Insurance for Residents and New Doctors: The Contract Rule

A signed employment contract may help a new doctor document income for disability coverage. Review carrier requirements, group benefits and future increase options.
Young doctor in a white coat walking outside a hospital in eastern Idaho with mountains in the background at sunrise

Disability insurers use documented income to determine the benefit they can offer. That usually means one or two years of tax returns. For a doctor moving out of training, a signed employment contract may support coverage based on the new salary instead. Carrier limits and underwriting still apply, and a future increase rider may help as income grows.

A resident’s tax returns reflect training pay rather than an attending salary. That can make it difficult to arrange coverage that matches the income expected from a new position.

Here’s how I discuss documentation, timing and existing benefits with doctors starting their careers.

Why does disability insurance need proof of income when life insurance doesn’t?

Disability insurance replaces part of your income, so the carrier needs a basis for determining the monthly benefit.

“If I wanna buy a life insurance policy, I can buy a lot of life insurance with you not making a lot of money. But to buy disability insurance, I have to show one or two years’ worth of taxes, or, if you’re brand new out of college, a contract.” — Kyle Bennett, Eagle Cap Insurance

Disability underwriting considers both health and income. The carrier reviews documentation to determine the benefit it can offer, subject to its coverage limits.

Tax returns may be sufficient for an established earner. For someone finishing residency, a signed contract can help document the higher income expected from the next role.

How can a signed employment contract help a new doctor qualify?

A signed contract can show the carrier the income you’re about to earn, so the benefit can be sized to that instead of your resident pay.

For example, suppose a doctor has signed an employment contract with an annual salary of $500,000. The carrier can assess that contract when considering the available benefit.

  1. The contract is the income proof. No tax history needed yet.
  2. The carrier works off that number. As a rule of thumb, I can get you about 60% of it in monthly benefit.
  3. Then the carrier’s ceiling applies. Every company has a maximum monthly benefit it will issue, so at physician incomes you may hit that cap before you hit 60%.

The 60% is my rule of thumb, not a promise, and it isn’t the same at every company. Each carrier sets its own limits, and your specialty and your own underwriting set the real figure.

Young physician in scrubs reviewing a signed employment contract at a hospital break-room table in eastern Idaho

What if you’re still a resident and haven’t signed a contract?

Ask which coverage is available during residency and what documents the carrier requires. Health changes before a later application can affect the offer.

“Everybody wants disability insurance once they’re disabled, and you’re a decline at that point.” — Kyle Bennett, Eagle Cap Insurance

A back injury, diagnosis or new prescription during training can change the terms a carrier offers or whether it will offer coverage. Consider that possibility alongside the timing of your expected income increase.

So for a resident the decision usually looks like this:

  • Buy a smaller individual policy now, based on what you can document today, and plan to increase it later with a future increase rider (more on that below).
  • Or wait for the signed contract and buy a larger policy then, accepting the risk that your health changes in the meantime.

Resident programs and accepted documentation vary by carrier. Review the available options for your stage of training rather than assuming every carrier uses the same rules.

Should a resident take the hospital’s group disability plan?

I generally recommend taking the short- and long-term disability coverage offered through work, then reviewing whether its benefits are sufficient for your circumstances.

Check these two features of the group plan:

  • When it starts and how long it pays. Short-term coverage often handles roughly the first 12 weeks, and most long-term policies have a 90-day waiting period. We break that gap down in how long long-term disability takes to kick in.
  • Who pays the premium. That decides whether benefits are taxed.
Group plan through your hospital or program Individual policy you own
How you get it Offered at work, often subsidized by the employer Bought through an agent, underwritten on your health and income
Taxes on benefits (IRS Pub. 525) Taxable to the extent the employer paid, or you paid pre-tax Generally not taxable if you paid with after-tax dollars
Sized to The plan’s formula Your documented income (or signed contract), up to the carrier’s maximum
Can add riders like future increase Usually not your choice Yes, when you buy it

The tax line matters more than people expect. According to IRS Publication 525, benefits from coverage your employer paid for are taxable income, while benefits from a policy you paid for entirely with after-tax dollars aren’t. If you and your employer split the cost, only the employer-paid share is taxed. Ask your tax professional how your own plan is set up.

What is a future increase rider, and why does it matter for new doctors?

It lets you raise your benefit later by proving your income went up, not by proving you’re still healthy.

Income can rise substantially after training. Without a future increase rider, adding coverage later may require new medical underwriting. Review the rider’s permitted increase dates, income requirements and limits before relying on it.

Here’s what the rider generally does, though the terms vary by carrier:

  • Lets you increase coverage without new medical underwriting. You still show income (pay stubs, tax returns, other disability coverage you carry).
  • Is typically available once a year until around age 55.
  • Usually has to be chosen when you first buy the policy. You can’t add it later. Guardian’s description of the future increase option lays out a typical version.

That option can let a resident begin with a smaller benefit and increase it as an attending, within the rider’s terms.

Insurance agent and a young doctor talking across an office desk in Ammon, Idaho while reviewing printed policy pages

What should a new doctor check before buying?

Start with the policy’s definition of disability, then compare the benefit and other terms. Ask these questions:

  1. How does the policy define disability? For anyone whose income depends on specialized hands-on work, this is the clause that decides claims. Our article on disability insurance for chiropractors and self-employed professionals walks through own-occupation wording and a real claim.
  2. What income will the carrier accept? Tax returns, a signed contract, or resident pay.
  3. What’s the monthly benefit, and what’s the carrier’s ceiling?
  4. Waiting period and benefit period. How long before it pays, and how long it pays.
  5. Is there a future increase rider? If not, ask why.
  6. Who pays the premium? That’s your tax answer.

An agent who works with several carriers can compare the definitions and features rather than only the monthly benefit. Our buyer’s guide to comparing disability insurance explains what to review.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a new doctor buy disability insurance before their first paycheck?

Often, yes. Disability insurance is sized to income you can document, and for someone just out of training a signed employment contract can serve as that proof instead of tax returns. Each carrier decides what it will accept, so bring the contract to the conversation.

How much disability insurance can a doctor get?

As a rule of thumb, about 60% of documented income, up to the carrier’s maximum monthly benefit. At physician incomes that ceiling can come into play, so the exact number depends on the carrier, your specialty and underwriting.

Is the disability coverage from my residency program or hospital enough?

Take it if it’s offered, but check what it pays, how long it pays, and who pays the premium. Under IRS Publication 525, benefits from employer-paid coverage are taxable, while benefits from a policy you paid for with after-tax dollars generally are not. You can layer an individual policy on top.

Why do doctors need a future increase rider?

Because your income will likely grow faster than your coverage. A future increase rider lets you buy more coverage later by proving your income went up, without new medical underwriting. It usually has to be added when you first buy the policy.


If you’ve signed a contract or expect to soon, we can review it alongside your existing group benefits and available individual policies. Set up a meeting with Kyle, or read about disability insurance at Eagle Cap.

This article is for general education and is not insurance or tax advice or an offer of coverage. Benefit limits, riders, definitions and eligibility vary by carrier and are subject to underwriting; the policy’s wording controls. Talk with a licensed agent about your situation and a tax professional about how your benefits would be taxed.


About the author:
Kyle Bennett is the principal of Eagle Cap Insurance, an independent agency serving eastern Idaho since 2008. He works with dozens of carriers from offices in Ammon (Idaho Falls area) and Preston, helping families and business owners with health, life, disability and business benefits.

In this article

Written by

Kyle Bennett
Licensed Agent · Eagle Cap Insurance

Talk to a licensed Idaho agent

Questions about your own coverage?

Kyle Bennett and the Eagle Cap Insurance team help individuals, families and business owners across Idaho Falls and Preston compare health, life, disability, business and Medicare coverage — with plain-language guidance from licensed local agents, not a call center.

Calling the number above will direct you to a Licensed Insurance Agent.

Keep reading

Related articles

We simplify insurance

Get plain-language guidance on your coverage

Licensed local advisors in Idaho Falls and Preston. No call center, no pressure.